Lumbar Total Disc Replacement vs Fusion: Which to Choose

What’s stopping total disc replacement from being a more common surgical option for lumbar spine issues? Find out from our expert.

Peer Reviewed

For close to two decades, many experts have asserted that lumbar total disc replacements (TDR) should be provided more often as treatment for degenerative disc disease. Yet many doctors still rely on the more widely adopted and traditional lumbar spinal fusion.

Spine surgeon helping patient choose between total disc replacement and lumbar fusionWhy is total disc replacement not a more common procedure?Why is that? If you wanted a TDR, would you be able to get one? And will insurance pay for it? Here’s what you need to know about TDR vs. fusion before you go under the knife.

Understanding TDR

For much of the late 20th century, the traditional fix for lumbar back pain was spinal fusion. In that procedure, a surgeon places a bone graft between two or more vertebrae, which eliminates painful or dangerous movement.

But over the early course of the 21st century, treating degenerative disc disease (DDD) with TDR increased nearly three times. TDR is technically more demanding than fusion; it completely replaces a worn out, even totally degenerated disc, with one that’s metal and/or plastic.

Certain studies show extensive benefits. As one in 2017 put it, “Lumbar TDR surgery was a safe procedure with overall low complication and revision rates, significant improvement in health-related quality of life...scores, and high rates of successful outcomes. Moreover, there are reports that mobility is preserved... .”

Richard Guyer, MD, is co-founder of the Texas Back Institute in Plano, TX, where he and colleagues have provided over 4,000 TDRs since the year 2000. He says, “We believe that in the right hands, at a center of excellence, the artificial disc can give prolonged and predictably very good results.”

Why Would I Need a Disc Replacement?

Low back problems hit more than a third of our population (about 38%) and it’s recognized that aging is undoubtedly a risk factor. Guyer actually thinks the term degenerative disc disease, should change. “It’s [really] not a disease; it’s a natural aging process,” he points out.

Illustration of spine to help determine TDR vs fusion surgeryTDR replaces a damaged disc, while fusion hooks two or more vertebrae together.

Fusion vs. TDR

One 2018 study explains fusion’s results as “eliminating motion at the affected segment [which] changes the [spine’s] mechanics…and [places] increased stress on neighboring segments.”

That lack of motion does have another benefit—it eliminates pain. That’s something TDR’s increased mobility can’t fully address. It can “only relieve pain generated from the disc, but not other sources.”

On the plus side, TDR studies repeatedly show it provides “motion preservation,” “reduces hospital stays,” and provides long-term durability, showing lower reoperation rates than fusion.

But Dr. Guyer admits TDR is a much more time-consuming procedure. “Unlike fusion...[for TDR] there’s a lot of decision-making...and a lot of prep time. [You’re] looking at the X-rays of the discs above and below, making sure you choose the right size. [So let’s say] the patient has a narrow disc space. You have to mobilize [that space] back to normal height; you can’t make it too high [or] too short,” he points out. Then to finish, your surgeon must make sure he or she has the disc anchored properly.

Barriers to TDR Adoption

Despite all of TDR’s benefits, a 2017 study noted five reasons why fusion is still the option most surgeons choose:

  • Strict indications on when TDR can be used—Insurers are still prone to only approve the older procedure.
  • Challenging surgical technique—“You hear about surgeons who are absolute wizards [at fusion]. But [TDR’s] a very demanding procedure,” Dr. Guyer says. Many doctors who’d already provided fusion for 20 years (or more) when TDR premiered in the early 21st century have been reluctant to climb on board.
  • Lack of device selection—Dr. Guyer admits this was an issue as late as 2013. But now, he says there are two models—the activL Artificial Disc, approved since 2015 and the ProDisc—and both have generated greater patient satisfaction.
  • Fear of late complications or revision surgeries—There are times when reoperations are needed, but both fusion and TDR patients face this concern.

The Reimbursement Challenge

This is the final obstacle the 2017 study mentioned. Yes, new products face challenges, but TDR’s been around 20+ years. The oldest of the “newer” models Dr. Guyer mentioned was approved in 2015.

Dr. Guyer says, “We’re now at about 85% of insurance coverage,” and admits that’s a great improvement from when he and others did that 2013 fusion versus TDR study. But the reimbursement to surgeons is still an obstacle. “Say you got reimbursed X for [traditional fusion surgery]; for TDR you get a fraction of that!” Dr. Guyer noted, adding the extra work in trying to get insurance reimbursement, “You say, ‘I’m just going to do a fusion.’”

Determining Your Need

Luckily, relatively few folks with back problems ever need a total disc replacement. And before undergoing either fusion or TDR, patients need to explore non-surgical therapies, ranging from NSAIDs to physical therapy, massage, and other rehab. Lab tests will also be needed.

Once an operation is deemed necessary, bring inquiries about both procedures. Younger people with DDD should question TDR’s long-term protection, since the durability even of the newer discs isn’t yet that well-known.

Finally, if you meet a surgeon who insists that fusion is your only option, ask why TDR can’t be considered. If your surgeon sharply dismisses TDR...sharply dismiss that surgeon and find another.

Updated on: 06/16/21
Continue Reading
Should You Get ACDF or Cervical Disc Replacement Surgery?
Richard D. Guyer, MD
Continue Reading:

Should You Get ACDF or Cervical Disc Replacement Surgery?

ACDF and disc replacement surgery can both take your neck pain and radiculopathy away. Which one’s right for you? Learn about how they’re similar and different to help you choose.
Read More